Editorial Series | August 1st, 2024
The Politics of Nostalgia - Sophie Hahn’s Mayoral Candidacy
By: Tim O’Brien
Second article in the series: Is Zionism Killing Berkeley? (Zionist is not a term I have been comfortable using in the past as it means different things to different people. For purposes of these articles, when I write ‘Zionist’ I mean a person or people for whom the lens through which they see things — current events, social justice, indigenous rights, racism, oppression, equality, liberation, and school curricula to name a few — is colored always by an “Israel-first” mentality.)
Council Member Hahn often opens her speaking engagements with reminiscences from her childhood as a way to introduce herself and present her Berkeley bona fides:
“Berkeley is more than just a great place to live for me. It’s who I am and what I stand for. My parents moved here to embrace civil rights and as a child I attended one of Berkeley’s first integrated schools. From my father’s shoulders I watched free speech and anti-war protests. … Truly inspired by the sense of possibility that electrified our community I learned early on that freedom, justice and equality are hard fought and that the things we do in Berkeley really matter. … I have been working to make Berkeley a stronger, safer and more equitable place for all of us and to express these values in everything we do. I believe in the intrinsic value of every human being and that everyone is worthy of dignity, respect and a safe, meaningful and comfortable life.”
Should Hahn be elected in November, it will be as Mayor of a Berkeley unrecognizable to her parents when they moved here. And much of that disconnect is thanks to Hahn herself. Her role in the erosion of many of the elements she touts in her nostalgic look back bears a closer look. They will be presented in detail in the body of the article.
As a child I attended one of Berkeley’s first integrated schools – As Council Member, Hahn has allied herself with the JCRC (a pro-Israel organization and lobbying apparatus) and a group of Berkeley parents who are engaged in a full frontal attack on Berkeley teachers and the District’s pioneering legacy of liberated ethnic studies.
From my father’s shoulders I watched free speech and anti-war protests – The same protests have been going on, on the same campus, for the past 10 months. To our knowledge, Hahn never once met with anti-war or pro-Palestine student activists or visited the encampment on Sproul Plaza or weighed in on efforts to silence students and faculty around the issue of Israel/Palestine. According to media accounts, she did venture onto campus twice, both times in solidarity with her pro-Israel constituency.
The things we do in Berkeley really matter – She’s right. The country and the world often look to us to lead the way in matters of social justice and international liberation. In spite of that, Hahn, as a member of the three person Agenda Committee has been intransigeant in her refusal to calendar a Ceasefire Resolution in spite of the community’s deep interest in the issue.
I have been working to make Berkeley a stronger, safer and more equitable place for all of us – No, she hasn’t. As you will see below, she has been working – since October 7th – to make Berkeley a safer place for some of her constituents but has been unmoved and in many cases dismissive of the safety and equity concerns of others, and has consistently refused to call out pro-Israel bad actors in our community.
and to express these values in everything we do – I can think of no more meaningful way to “express the values of Berkeley” in these current international circumstances, than to have calendared and passed a Gaza Ceasefire Resolution, two things Hahn has refused to do.
I believe in the intrinsic value of every human being and that everyone is worthy of dignity, respect and a safe, meaningful and comfortable life. – What she means here is every human being … except Palestinians. Where is the dignity and respect in Gaza? Who there is living a safe, meaningful and comfortable life as they shuttle from rubble pile to rubble pile hoping to live one more day? And she has the opportunity to throw Berkeley’s outsized voice into the call for dignity and respect for the right of Palestinians to live that safe, meaningful and comfortable life. Her reluctance to stand up for that, is why we need to confront Zionism in our community and make sure that our elected representatives don’t get a pass on starry-eyed platitudes that don’t apply to everyone.
The Assault on Berkeley Schools
For a more in-depth breakdown of these tactics see Why Has Berkeley’s pro-Israel Fringe Set Their Sights on the Peace & Justice Commission? – Berkeley Flipside.
Shortly after Hamas’ deadly incursion of October 7th, a group of Jewish BUSD parents announced they were organizing, ostensibly around the issue of combating antisemitism and student safety in our schools – two universally embraced concepts in Berkeley. It soon became apparent however that fighting antisemitism was not the defining goal of the group (“BUSD Jewish Parents”). Several Jewish parents, themselves concerned about antisemitism and student safety either dropped out or were excluded from future communications when it became clear that their sense of Judaism was not sufficiently pro-Israel for the group’s main mission: an attack on BUSD’s proud legacy of teaching liberated Ethnic Studies, which included targeting individual teachers who dared to speak about Palestine in the classroom or even offer students a safe space to discuss it among themselves.
This assault on our teachers and pedagogy has resulted in numerous teachers being publicly doxxed for their views, school phones being flooded by irate callers from across the country, a complaint filed with the Department of Education by the Trump-aligned Brandeis Center and the Anti-Defamation League, an erstwhile civil rights organization. A Jewish parent later filed a lawsuit against the District demanding access to classroom instruction materials on Israel before they’re taught. Both of these moves are anti-community, and a direct assault on Berkeley’s ability to educate our kids as they sap much-needed resources that could go to other areas, like trying to close the achievement gap between white students and students of color.
One might expect a council member who repeatedly celebrates our schools in her pro forma introduction to rush to the defense of our teachers and schools. But Council Member Hahn quickly threw her lot in with the forces intent on bullying our teachers and tailoring the education of our kids to their views. In an email to one of the parents (Stacy Zolt Hara, who sits on Berkeleyside’s Parent Company’s Board) which was later forwarded to the larger group, (made available to Flipside by one of the parents) Hahn affirms her commitment to these forces: “I have also worked behind the scenes at BUSD to address the concerns you organized around at our schools, and continue to engage with School Board members and staff around this and other issues of concern, including BUSD’s choice of consultants to implement ethnic studies curriculum.” In other words, I am your partner in this and will do what I can to make sure that what is taught in our schools does not undermine at-home indoctrination. Just like other white people are demanding in Florida.
Later in the email Hahn touts her connections to a pro-Israel lobby group: “I have close relationships with leadership at JCRC (Jewish Community Relations Council) and worked with them to create a movement against cities taking action on this conflict for precisely the reasons you cite.” It begs credulity to think of another country whose lobbyists would be so openly welcomed into the halls of Berkeley’s municipal government. As a kind of final thumb in the eye to the hundreds of pro-Ceasefire constituents whose emails she ignores, whose questions she refuses to answer and whose meetings she declines to take, Hahn closes her email to Zolt Hara: “If you’d like to meet to discuss additional strategies around these issues, I am happy to sit down with you at any time.” Hahn’s message is clear: If you are pro-Israel, I am here for you. If you are anti-war, don’t bother knocking.
King Middle School Student Walkout
Nowhere has Hahn’s post-October 7th political mindframe and compromised civic judgment been on greater display than it was on May 10, 2024. That was the day students at King Middle School, in Hahn’s District, planned a walkout and march to Sproul Plaza where they would join with Cal students at their encampment in solidarity with the Palestinian people suffering and dying in Gaza. I need not remind many of you that student walkouts are in the DNA of Berkeley public schools. Over the years they have been variably planned, encouraged, facilitated, or at least acknowledged by staff. But in the new post-October 7th paradigm, protests have suddenly become controversial and ‘divisive’ – the great new catch word to quell dissent and resistance – and subject to relentless oversight and criticism from parents angry at the school district’s perceived unwillingness to preserve the sanctity of their private instruction on the matter. And so the School District, under intense pressure from pro-Israel parents, decided that they would not send staff along with the unauthorized walkout, because it was more important to appease those entitled voices than insure the safety of their students. In the end, no doubt because they saw the reckless inanity of such a rationale, they sent two staff members along as observers.
The morning of the walkout, some potentially antisemitic graffiti appeared on a board in one of King’s classrooms and someone took a photo of it which quickly made its way to Council Member Hahn. By mid-morning Hahn was aware of the incident and had responded to the school. So overcome with her post-October 7th sense of righteousness, Hahn took the unusual, highly inappropriate and possibly illegal step of publishing a photo of the classroom board on X, formerly Twitter.
In addition to legal issues around publishing photos taken inside a classroom, Hahn neglected to redact the names of the juvenile students, another abdication of her duty as an elected rep. And that’s the thing about Zionism, and why it is concerning in our elected representatives, because frequently all one’s past experiences and even mores and good judgment recede before the new all-important cause. When the possible illegality of the post was pointed out to Hahn, she quickly took it down. (In deference to the kids’ privacy and the law, Flipside has redacted the names of the students here, but we are in possession of the original screenshot from Hahn’s X page with no such redactions.)
In part because the School District refused to take a more active role in the student planned walkout, the march took some early meandering and arguably ill-advised turns, bringing them along the Jewish Community Center on Walnut St., a few blocks from King. As one would expect, this was widely decried by the local pro-Israel community who characterized the mostly black and brown 11-14 year olds living out their Berkeley values, as pro-Hamas and terrorizing Jewish preschoolers. Vicious accusations flew around demanding to know who planned the route and why they targeted the JCC.
So at first blush, here’s what Berkeley’s pro-Israel community – with Councilmember Hahn leading the charge – put out as happened. Heinous, antisemitic graffiti that the school district refuses to do anything about was discovered in a classroom on the morning of a pro-Hamas march that targeted Jewish preschool kids at the local Jewish Community Center.
Here’s what actually happened that day. Flipside has learned that the ‘antisemitic graffiti’ that prompted Hahn to abandon her judgment was actually written as a joke by one Jewish student about another Jewish student. Remember, they’re middle schoolers who sometimes act like … middle schoolers. Though she writes in her indignant post – again putting herself in a kind of opposition to BUSD: “I’m waiting for BUSD to call it what is and keep all students safe.” Well, I think privacy concerns will almost certainly keep BUSD from calling it what it is, so Council Member, why don’t you? Two Jewish middle school kids messing around with each other. Reminds one of the tree in the forest conundrum. If a Jewish kid makes fun of another Jewish kid’s Jewishness, is it antisemitic? There has been no acknowledgment or apology from Councilmember Hahn. Instead, it’s what always seems to happen when such reasoning and actions are exposed … crickets.
And while the kids did pass by the JCC, there was no taunting or stopping. What it was was a group of young kids, mostly of color, on a protest of conscience on a public street that moved past the JCC. But guess what else happened on the march? The kids were set upon by a number of angry adult residents including this older white woman spewing hate and flipping off the kids, many of whom had no idea what she was talking about.
And that’s the problem with Zionism and why we need to stand up to it in Berkeley, because people lose their minds in its pursuit. Remember when a white woman flipping off black and brown pre-teens and calling them terrorists was something that Berkeley’s elected officials would not tolerate? But not anymore. Now everything is viewed through “context.” This hateful and incredibly inappropriate behavior towards children happened in Councilmember Hahn’s district, the same Councilmember Hahn who is antiracist and loves to trumpet that Berkeley Stands United Against Hate. To our knowledge, Councilmember Hahn has done nothing to address this incident. One can only conclude that it is not the kind of hate that bothers her in her district. Flipside was able to identify the woman and attempted to interview her. We were cut off at the front door by a man who asked us: “Do you think that chanting from the river to the sea is calling for the destruction of the state of Israel?” And again, it is this lack of personal accountability and the abdication of norms of conduct that are so unsettling. What does that expression have to do with an older woman spewing hate at and flipping off middle schoolers? It’s this reluctance to just say, you know what, that is wrong. No. Never. It’s always somebody else’s fault that legitimizes the conduct, in this case a bunch of middle schoolers. As one of the parent chaperones told Flipside: “The thing that most surprised me was that an elder woman would speak to such a young kid with such hate. Her reaction was dehumanizing. Calling them Hamas, saying they didn’t have any idea about history. Mad in a way that was not triggered by their presence but triggered by something much deeper.” If Councilmember Hahn is interested in addressing this hateful behavior by a voter in her district we would be happy to forward her the woman’s name and address.
Her Father’s Shoulders
In 2016 and 2020, we were living in District 5 and I voted for Sophie Hahn. She said the right things, seemed nice enough, had a great Berkeley pedigree – I’m a Cal grad as well and remain slightly biased in favor of fellow Bears – so I voted for her. And frankly I didn’t give it another thought for years. I have never really been involved in Berkeley politics or followed the City Council. But as the carnage in Gaza drew on into November with no end in sight, I was confused why the City of Berkeley, always out front on so many national and international issues of social justice was not calling for a Ceasefire. I went online and discovered an Antiracism page on Sophie’s website. On it, she highlighted the words of leftist icon Angela Davis: “In a racist society it is not enough to be non-racist, we must be anti-racist.” A noble notion and one I agree with. I reached out to Council Member Hahn asking her to consider a Ceasefire Resolution with another quotation from Ms. Davis: “Palestine is a moral litmus test for the world.” I also pointed out that Ms. Davis stands unequivocally against the racist slaughter going on in Gaza. The page has since been taken down, and the old link only brings you to an ‘unsupported protocol’ page Anti-Racism Resources Page – Sophie 2020. I will confess I enjoyed the irony that Antiracism is an ‘unsupported protocol’ of Zionism.
On October 6th Angela Davis was a hero to Sophie Hahn, so much so that Hahn created a whole city-based Antiracism Resource page, essentially in Davis’ honor. In the months since October 7th, Hahn apparently has felt compelled to dissociate herself from Davis, remove the antiracism page and move on to new heroes, who apparently are more in line with her views on Israel and Palestine. There go Gandhi, Muhammad Ali, and Nelson Mandela as well. James Baldwin too gets shitcanned for his support of Palestinian freedom and statements like: “When white men rise up against oppression, they are heroes. When black (and brown) men rise, they have reverted to their native savagery.” I want a mayor who has the same heroes today as they did on October 6, 2023.
In the 60s Hahn sat atop her dad’s shoulders on Sproul Plaza marveling at the Free Speech movement and anti-war protests. Today, she is unmoved by very real threats to Free Speech on campus trying to suppress pro-Palestinian voices, and if moved at all, appears ambivalent about repressing it. As for the anti-war piece, for months Cal students opposed to the war in Gaza protested, demonstrated and eventually peacefully encamped on Sproul Plaza in an effort to get the administration to hear their demands. It was reminiscent of my time at Cal in the 80s when we protested and encamped for divestment from the other apartheid, South Africa. And just like at that movement and at the Free Speech and anti-war movements before it, visitors made pilgrimages to Sproul Plaza this Spring with small children on their shoulders to give them a glimpse at history and show them what people of conscience can do when they mobilize together. To my knowledge – and through conversations with several of the student leaders – Hahn never visited the encampment or tried to engage with student activists.
I am aware of two times when Council Member Hahn went on campus at Cal in any sort of official capacity. One was in solidarity with Jewish students at a demonstration calling attention to antisemitism on campus in which many jewish students expressed feelings of being unsafe and unwelcome on campus. And the other was when she met with student attendees at the rescheduled talk of the rightwing lawyer and IDF reservist Ran Bar Yoshafat, a Netanyahu ally whose meteoric rise in Israeli legal circles is largely tied to his association with the Kohelet Policy Forum, a shill organization for Netanyahu’s attempt to dismantle the Israeli Supreme Court. Bar Yoshafat’s racist policies and pronouncements basically legitimize the bombing of all civilian infrastructure in Gaza. “Every school, mosque, hospital, kindergarten – all – without exception is a terror camp. There is no exception. There is not even one exception.” — Ran Bar Yoshafat. His prior scheduled talk had been derailed by protests that broke windows and intimidated attendees, including allegations of nasty and repugnant antisemitic name calling.
I endorse Council Member Hahn’s outreach to pro-Israel Jewish students at Cal. Everyone should feel safe on campus. But why only the pro-Israel students? What about, in her capacity as City Council Member, outreach to other students who are also hurting? Students whose family members have been killed in Gaza, Jewish students troubled by the killing being done in their name or kids just so distracted and overwhelmed by the US-funded humanitarian apocalypse in Gaza that they can’t study properly? It’s as if their pain and anxiety don’t register for Sophie. They don’t count. That’s not the kind of leader we need.
Stronger, Safer and More Equitable Place for All of Us
Hahn has spoken out about hate crimes against Berkeley businesses, sat with Cal students to share their pain, and stood up for Berkeley residents brutalized by rightwing racists. Unfortunately however, if you are against the ongoing massacre of children and other civilians in Gaza or the indefensible extrajudicial taking of land in the West Bank, that line reads like this: Hahn has refused to condemn hate crimes against Berkeley businesses, ignored the pain of Cal students and looked away when Berkeley residents have been brutalized by rightwing racists.
We recently posted an article on the recent spate of hate crimes in Berkeley against businesses displaying pro-Palestinian signage and Council Member Hahn’s refusal to denounce or even acknowledge them. As detailed in the article, we reached out to all three mayoral candidates for comment on this issue and received clear denunciations from Adena Ishii and Kate Harrison. Council Member Hahn declined to comment.
On August 15th I spoke with Council Member Hahn at her drop in at the Farmer’s Market and asked her why she has not spoken out about these hate crimes. She told me she can’t speak out about every bad thing that happens in Berkeley.
At last week’s City Council meeting, Council Member Cecilia Lunaparra brought up the plight of an unnamed Berkeley City College student who was in the West Bank as an observer trying to stave off Israeli settlers (in settlements deemed illegal by international law) from stealing more Palestinian land. The group was attacked and he was beaten with a metal rod and quite severely disfigured.
While several residents brought the issue up during public comment, not a single Council Member besides Lunaparra commented on it. No sympathy or compassion for the poor fellow, no outrage on behalf of a Berkeley resident no matter how brutalized. He was there to help Palestinians, probably got what he deserved, … NEXT! This is the city government we as Berkeley voters are empowering. This is the troubling post-October 7th landscape we are enabling by not standing up to these forces. We need a mayor who sees everyone. Someone who can look at that face and feel something for their constituent, rather than dismiss it based on his perceived political leanings.
Access and Public Financing
I do not know how accessible Council Member Hahn was before October 7th. Though she was my representative for nearly seven years I never had cause or occasion to reach out to her. Since then, as has been duly noted, she has completely closed herself off to a large swath of Berkeley voters.
Another form of access is showing up to public events and forums. The Wellstone Democratic Renewal Club is the largest Democratic Club in Alameda County and regularly hosts candidate forums and debates for all major offices in the area. On May 24, 2024, they hosted a debate in Oakland that featured – or was supposed to feature – panels on both the Berkeley mayoral race (Harrison, Ishii, Hahn). and our local state senate race (Jesse Arreguin, Jovanka Beckles). Flipside spoke with Pamela Drake, a 20 year member of the club and current Local Politics Chair, who moderated the forum. She said all five candidates had committed to the event, then a day and a half before the debate “Jesse punked out. … Then the next day Sophie did too.” We asked if it was unusual for candidates to skip Wellstone Club debates. “It’s the first time I ever remember it happening,” she said. “It was a huge disappointment. We’d publicized it for a while and had spent quite a bit of time constructing questions.” One can’t help but wonder if a leading factor in the decision by the two architects of the City of Berkeley’s pro-Israel position, was a desire to avoid confrontation related to that issue.
Candidate Kate Harrison and an empty chair at the Wellstone Democratic Club mayoral debate.
In 2016, Berkeley passed Measure X1. A reaction to the reality that only rich people and those backed by outside and corporate money could win elections, it instituted public financing of campaigns in Berkeley to bring a measure of fairness that allows people who work and come from less means to run competitive races. Contributions from Berkeley voters are capped at $60, but matched 6:1 by the city, so that a $60 contribution becomes $420 for the campaign. If a candidate opts in to public financing, they are limited to giving their own campaign $270.
The measure exemplifies the Berkeley ethos that both centers the voice of Berkeley voters and gives meaning to the belief that everyone deserves a seat at the table. As former Council Member Lori Droste observed: “If you have significant Berkeley support it makes it much easier to raise money.” Alone among the mayoral candidates, Hahn has declined the public financing option for her campaign. This allows her to fundraise on a wider scale, with a higher maximum dollar limit on contributions from non-Berkeley residents and organizations. Given the local, national and international media attention given to Berkeley’s refusal to pass a Ceasefire Resolution as well as the high profile, education-based complaints and lawsuits, one would expect outside money to likely flow into Hahn’s campaign coffers. As per July’s campaign disclosures, Hahn has received 38% of her money – more than $71,000 – from people and interests outside of Berkeley, much of it from venture capitalists, corporate CEOs and lobbyists. The whole reason Berkeley passed public financing of elections was to prevent outside big money interests from influencing our elections and government.
Hahn also has considerable family wealth that she can bring to bear in her campaign since, according to City Clerk Mark Numainville, there is no limit on the amount of money a candidate can give to their own campaign if they opt out of public financing.
___________
Several pro-Israel speakers at Berkeley City Council meetings over the past months have referenced a world famous work of ancient mythology to buttress their position. So allow me to borrow a passage from it to illustrate mine, Matthew 6:24-26 (with allowance for substitution at the end): “No one can serve two masters. Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve both Berkeley and Israel.”
Berkeley needs a leader devoted to Berkeley and the progressive work that, at its best, has characterized and defined our town, undiluted by allegiances to a repressive, rightwing regime halfway around the world. We need someone for whom October 7th did not change their heroes or their positions on: social justice, racial justice, indigenous rights or the commitment to the idea that all people deserve to be free. We need a mayor who doesn’t look to see if a business owner is wearing a keffiyeh before deciding whether or not the vandalism to their store should be taken seriously. Or, in the words of one increasingly schizophrenic Berkeley city council member: someone who truly believes in the intrinsic value of every human being and that everyone is worthy of dignity, respect and a safe, meaningful and comfortable life.
Long live Berkeley!
